The Yogurt Shop Murders has gripped audiences for over 30 years, but in August 2025, the infamous case is returning to the spotlight with a fresh perspective in HBO’s brand new true crime documentary series. The first episode of The Yogurt Shop Murders premiered on HBO and Max on August 3, 2025, at 10 p.m. ET/PT, kicking off a four-part weekly event that promises deep dives into the never-solved case and exclusive interviews only now coming to light.
Episode Guide & Streaming Details
Telling the harrowing story of the 1991 Austin, Texas murders—where four teenage girls were brutally killed at an I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt! store—the series investigates not just the original crime, but decades of impact on victims’ families, law enforcement, and the community. The Yogurt Shop Murders delivers rare access to police, journalists, and the families themselves, uncovering new material including never-before-seen footage and a focus on recent advances that keep the case alive.
Key Points Summary
- Premiere: August 3, 2025, 10 p.m. ET/PT on HBO/Max.
- Weekly Episodes: Every Sunday at 10 p.m. ET/PT.
- How to Watch: HBO (cable), Max (streaming), and platforms like Prime Video or Sling with HBO add-ons.
- Docuseries Length: Four episodes, each uncovering a new angle of the case.
- Global Access: Available on Crave in Canada and Sky/Now in the U.K.—check your country’s providers for details.
| Episode | Title | Air Date | Where to Watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fire and Water | Aug. 3, 2025 | HBO, Max |
| 2 | The Fifth Victim | Aug. 10, 2025 | HBO, Max |
| 3 | Mental Evidence | Aug. 17, 2025 | HBO, Max |
| 4 | In Your Own Time | Aug. 24, 2025 | HBO, Max |
Streaming on Max requires a subscription: $9.99/month with ads, $16.99/month ad-free, or $20.99/month for premium 4K streaming. HBO can also be added through select streaming bundles for flexible viewing options.
The Yogurt Shop Murders stands out for its in-depth look, not only at the tragedy and its aftermath but at questions that still haunt investigators and families. Director Margaret Brown spent over three years working with survivors, law enforcement, and those once accused, combining fresh interviews and new evidence to challenge prevailing theories. Produced by A24 and Fruit Tree (the company behind Emma Stone and Dave McCary), the series is as much a story of memory and justice as it is of the crime itself.
If you’re fascinated by American true crime or seeking insight into why the Yogurt Shop Murders remain unsolved, this docuseries is shaping up to be essential Sunday night viewing.
Stay tuned for new episodes every week and share your reactions or any thoughts about the investigation—this story isn’t over yet!