Comedian and podcaster Dave Smith has sent shockwaves through political circles with his stunning apology for supporting Donald Trump in 2024, coupled with a bold call for the president’s impeachment and removal. Known for his libertarian views and frequent appearances on platforms like The Joe Rogan Experience, Smith’s dramatic shift has sparked intense debate among fans and critics alike. This unexpected move, announced on June 16, 2025, during an interview on the YouTube show Breaking Points, highlights growing tensions within Trump’s support base over recent Middle East conflicts. Let’s dive into the details of this bombshell moment and what it means for Smith’s influence in the political landscape.
Why Dave Smith Apologized for Backing Trump
Smith, a prominent voice in libertarian circles, endorsed Trump in 2024 largely due to the former president’s promise to commute the sentence of Ross Ulbricht, the Silk Road founder. Trump fulfilled this pledge on January 21, 2025, earning praise from Smith and other libertarians. However, Smith’s support unraveled over Trump’s handling of escalating tensions between Israel and Iran. During his Breaking Points appearance, Smith slammed Trump’s response to Israel’s airstrikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities, which triggered missile exchanges. He called Trump’s push for renewed nuclear talks with Iran “a joke” and likened it to negotiating with Japan after Pearl Harbor. Smith’s frustration stemmed from Trump’s apparent betrayal of his campaign promise to avoid foreign wars, a core reason for his initial endorsement.
This pivot has divided Smith’s audience. Some praise his willingness to admit a mistake, while others view it as a hasty reaction to a single policy disagreement. The comedian’s outspoken regret has fueled discussions about the fragility of Trump’s coalition, especially among anti-war supporters.
Dave Smith’s Call for Impeachment Sparks Controversy
In a move that stunned hosts Krystal Ball and Saagar Enjeti, Dave Smith didn’t just retract his support—he demanded Trump’s impeachment and removal. Labeling Trump an “impotent leader,” Smith argued that the president’s actions in the Israel-Iran conflict contradicted his anti-war rhetoric. This call aligns Smith with other disillusioned Trump backers, like former Fox News host Tucker Carlson, who warned that a war with Iran could spell the end of Trump’s presidency. The backlash reflects growing unease among some conservatives and libertarians over Trump’s foreign policy decisions.
Smith’s impeachment demand has drawn mixed reactions. Critics on social media argue he’s overreacting, pointing out that impeachment requires specific constitutional grounds, which Smith didn’t clearly articulate. Supporters, however, see his stance as a principled rejection of war-mongering. The controversy has amplified Smith’s visibility, with clips of his Breaking Points interview going viral across platforms like X.
The Bigger Picture: Dave Smith’s Influence and Libertarianism
Dave Smith, host of the Part of the Problem podcast, has long been a polarizing figure. His blend of comedy, political commentary, and libertarian ideology resonates with a young, skeptical audience. Smith’s decision to back Trump in 2024, despite criticizing him in the past, raised eyebrows among purist libertarians. His recent reversal underscores the challenges of aligning with any major political figure while maintaining ideological consistency. As a member of the Libertarian Party’s Mises Caucus, Smith’s influence extends beyond comedy clubs to political conventions, where he spoke in 2024.
This saga highlights the broader tensions within the libertarian movement. Many, like Smith, supported Trump for specific policy promises but now grapple with his actions in office. The Israel-Iran conflict, with its heavy civilian toll—224 reported deaths in Iran and 24 in Israel—has become a flashpoint for anti-interventionist critics. Smith’s bold stance may inspire other libertarians to reconsider their political alliances.
What’s Next for Dave Smith and Trump’s Base?
Smith’s apology and impeachment call mark a pivotal moment in his career. Will he double down on his anti-Trump rhetoric, or will he refocus on broader libertarian issues? His next moves could shape his credibility among fans and foes. Meanwhile, Trump’s coalition faces growing cracks, with figures like Carlson and now Smith voicing dissent. The president’s response—defending Israel while warning Iran on Truth Social—hasn’t quelled the unrest.
For now, Dave Smith remains a lightning rod for debate. His willingness to admit a “bad calculation” sets him apart in a polarized political climate, but it also risks alienating his base. As the Israel-Iran situation evolves, expect Smith to stay vocal, whether through his podcast or high-profile interviews.
Stay tuned for updates on Dave Smith’s next moves and the fallout from his Trump reversal. Follow our blog for the latest political insights and join the conversation in the comments below!