Are Willson Contreras and William Contreras brothers? This is a question that baseball fans across the United States have been asking frequently, especially as both brothers continue to shine during the 2025 MLB season. The answer is a resounding yes — they are brothers, and their shared rise from humble beginnings in Venezuela to becoming two of the top catchers in Major League Baseball is nothing short of remarkable.
Their bond, talent, and contrasting career paths have made their story one of the most compelling narratives in the sport. Whether they’re facing each other in National League Central rivalry matchups or being recognized on the national stage, Willson and William Contreras have carved out a legacy that extends beyond statistics.
A Shared Beginning in Venezuela
The Contreras brothers were born and raised in Puerto Cabello, Venezuela, a place where baseball is woven into everyday life. Growing up in a modest but tight-knit household, Willson and William spent their childhood playing baseball in streets, fields, and local leagues. Their parents, William Sr. and Olga, were instrumental in nurturing their love for the game, making sacrifices to ensure their sons had opportunities to pursue their dreams.
The brothers were competitive from an early age. They pushed each other constantly — hitting balls, catching for each other, and creating imaginary big-league scenarios in their backyard. While many siblings share childhood dreams, few manage to make them a reality on baseball’s biggest stage.
Willson Contreras: The Trailblazer
Willson Contreras, born in 1992, is the older brother by six years. He became the first of the two to sign a professional contract, joining the Chicago Cubs organization in 2009 as an international free agent.
His early years in the minor leagues were not glamorous. Willson switched positions several times before settling behind the plate as a catcher — a move that would ultimately define his career. His breakout came in 2016, when he made his MLB debut in unforgettable fashion. Facing the Pittsburgh Pirates at Wrigley Field, he homered on the first pitch he saw.
That season, he became a central figure in the Cubs’ historic 2016 World Series championship — their first title in 108 years. His leadership, defensive growth, and powerful bat turned him into a fan favorite in Chicago. Over the next several years, he earned multiple All-Star selections and became one of the league’s most respected catchers.
In 2023, he made a bold career decision, signing with the St. Louis Cardinals, the Cubs’ biggest rival. This move surprised many but showed his willingness to embrace new challenges and leadership roles on a team looking to rebuild around veteran talent.
William Contreras: The Rising Star
William Contreras, born in 1998, followed a different path. In 2015, he signed with the Atlanta Braves as a teenager. Unlike his older brother, William’s hitting talent was evident early on. His progress through the minor leagues was steady, and by 2020, he made his MLB debut.
William’s offensive prowess stood out quickly. He showcased the rare combination of power and average that few catchers possess. By 2022, he had earned his first All-Star selection, making a name for himself as one of the top young players in the game.
Later that year, he was traded to the Milwaukee Brewers in a three-team deal that would define the next phase of his career. In Milwaukee, William became the starting catcher and quickly grew into a team leader. His offensive consistency and improving defensive skills turned him into one of the cornerstones of the Brewers’ roster.
In 2025, he has emerged as a legitimate MVP candidate, hitting for power, getting on base at an elite rate, and playing with confidence well beyond his years.
Two Brothers, One Position
One of the most remarkable aspects of their story is that both brothers play the same position: catcher. This position is arguably the most demanding in baseball, requiring not only physical skill but also leadership, game-calling intelligence, and the ability to build trust with pitchers.
- Willson Contreras
- Age: 33
- Position: Catcher
- Team: St. Louis Cardinals
- Debut: 2016 (Chicago Cubs)
- Highlights: 3× All-Star, 2016 World Series Champion, veteran leader known for power hitting and a strong throwing arm.
- William Contreras
- Age: 27
- Position: Catcher
- Team: Milwaukee Brewers
- Debut: 2020 (Atlanta Braves)
- Highlights: 2× All-Star, Silver Slugger Award winner, MVP contender in 2025, dynamic offensive catcher with improving defensive presence.
Willson is the fiery veteran, known for his leadership and emotional intensity. William represents the modern offensive catcher — a player who blends athleticism and production at an elite level. Despite their stylistic differences, both share a reputation for hard work and competitiveness.
Rivalry With Respect: Brewers vs. Cardinals
The story gets even more intriguing because both brothers now play in the National League Central Division. Willson is with the St. Louis Cardinals, while William stars for the Milwaukee Brewers. This makes their matchups not just family reunions but high-stakes rivalry games.
When Milwaukee and St. Louis meet, all eyes are on the Contreras brothers. Fans get to witness something rare — two brothers, both elite catchers, calling games for their respective teams on opposite sides of the diamond. Their parents often attend wearing split jerseys, supporting both sons equally.
While their competitive spirits shine during games, their post-game interactions often reflect their close bond. They’ve both mentioned in interviews that it feels surreal to play against each other, but they embrace it as a sign of how far they’ve come.
A Shared All-Star Moment
One of the highlights of their shared journey came during the 2022 MLB All-Star Game, when both brothers were selected to represent the National League. Willson started at catcher, while William served as the designated hitter.
It was a moment of immense pride — not just for the Contreras family, but for baseball fans around the world. Seeing two brothers on the same All-Star team, both excelling at the highest level, showcased the power of family, perseverance, and shared dreams.
Their 2025 Season: Dominance and Leadership
As of October 2025, both brothers are playing key roles for their respective teams:
- William Contreras is enjoying a career-best season with the Milwaukee Brewers. He has become the offensive engine of the team, leading in multiple statistical categories and guiding a young pitching staff through a playoff push. His performance has placed him firmly in the National League MVP conversation.
- Willson Contreras remains a crucial figure for the St. Louis Cardinals. Despite dealing with injuries earlier in the season, he has returned to form in the second half. His leadership has been vital for a team in transition, and his bat continues to provide veteran stability in the lineup.
Their simultaneous success has made the question “Are Willson Contreras and William Contreras brothers?” more relevant than ever. Their presence in the league isn’t a passing storyline — it’s an enduring legacy.
Why Their Story Resonates With Fans
The Contreras brothers’ story is about more than just baseball. It resonates because it combines themes of family, resilience, and excellence.
- Family Legacy: Two brothers excelling at the same challenging position is a rare and inspiring feat.
- Cultural Impact: Their journey from Venezuela inspires countless young players dreaming of making it to MLB.
- Unique Rivalry: Their presence on division rival teams adds emotional depth to Cardinals–Brewers matchups.
- Consistency: Both have sustained excellence over multiple seasons, proving their achievements are built to last.
- Genuine Connection: Their relationship is authentic, and fans appreciate seeing their mutual respect and support.
Their story connects with audiences beyond team loyalties, offering something universal: the power of family in the pursuit of greatness.
A Legacy That’s Still Being Written
So, are Willson Contreras and William Contreras brothers? Absolutely. But they are more than that — they are living proof of how shared dreams, dedication, and family bonds can shape extraordinary careers.
From playing in the streets of Venezuela to starring in MLB stadiums across America, their journey continues to inspire fans, players, and families everywhere. Whether they’re side by side at an All-Star Game or facing off in a heated rivalry, Willson and William Contreras are etching their names into baseball history.
What’s your favorite moment from the Contreras brothers’ careers? Share your thoughts below and join the conversation about this extraordinary MLB family.