Prime Video’s thriller series has gripped audiences with its dark narrative and emotional twists. If you’re wondering who killed Adam Macintosh in The Better Sister, you’re certainly not alone. The question has swept across social platforms, igniting heated debates and sharp speculation since the show’s dramatic season one finale. As of July 25, 2025, here’s the complete breakdown of the answer—plus the latest updates and what’s next for these unforgettable characters.
The Better Sister Finale – Answers and Aftermath
After months of theorizing, The Better Sister delivered a gut-punch ending that continues to trend. Viewers watched as Chloe Taylor (Jessica Biel) and her estranged sister Nicky (Elizabeth Banks) navigated a family tragedy after Adam Macintosh (Corey Stoll), Chloe’s high-profile lawyer husband, was found murdered in their exclusive Hamptons home. At first, almost everyone—from fans to detectives—asked the crucial question: who killed Adam Macintosh in The Better Sister?
The latest updates confirm with certainty: Nicky is the one who killed Adam. The shocking revelation came after an intense build-up, with suspicion falling on Adam’s teenage son Ethan and even Chloe herself. Only in the closing episodes did the truth about Adam’s murder finally unravel in a scene filled with raw confrontation and heartbreak.
Key Points Summary
- Adam Macintosh, a respected attorney, is found dead—a murder that unravels fiercely guarded family secrets.
- Ethan Macintosh, Adam’s son, is arrested after his DNA is discovered at the scene, but he is ultimately found not guilty.
- Nicky, Chloe’s estranged sister and Ethan’s biological mother, confesses to the killing.
- Nicky’s motives were rooted in protecting Chloe from Adam’s abuse, culminating in a physical altercation where Nicky fatally stabbed Adam.
- Chloe orchestrates a cover-up to frame another suspect, ensuring Nicky avoids prosecution.
- The finale leaves the family deeply changed, and viewers questioning the price of loyalty.
What Really Happened That Night?
The Better Sister’s main mystery pivots on a tangle of motives and secrets. Adam, both charismatic and deeply flawed, had a complicated past. He was once married to Nicky before marrying her sister, Chloe. This tangled web set the perfect backdrop for suspicion, as both sisters had suffered from his manipulations and abuse.
On the night of Adam’s death, emotions flared in their Hamptons home. As Nicky confronted Adam about his abusive behavior toward Chloe, the situation escalated violently. In the heat of their fight, Adam strangled Nicky. In an act of self-defense, she reached for a knife and fatally stabbed him in the neck.
After the killing, only Chloe knew what truly transpired. In a desperate bid to protect Nicky and their family, Chloe managed to frame Bill Braddock, Adam’s colleague, by planting the murder weapon and diverting suspicion. The police closed the case with Braddock’s arrest, allowing Nicky and Ethan to move forward.
Public and Critical Reaction
The finale has sparked passionate responses across social media and entertainment media. Critics have praised the series for its handling of trauma, sisterly bonds, and the blurred lines of morality. Many have called it one of the most emotional and unexpected conclusions to a crime thriller in recent years.
Actual feedback from viewers reflects the show’s impact:
- “Never saw that twist coming. The family secrets kept me guessing until the last minute.”
- “The performances in the final episode were intense, especially as the truth about Adam’s death was revealed.”
- “The way Chloe shielded Nicky and Ethan was both heartbreaking and heroic.”
Future of The Better Sister
As of today, there’s still no official word on a second season. The series, originally billed as a limited event, wrapped up the primary storyline from Alafair Burke’s bestselling novel. However, the immense popularity and the final shot’s lingering questions have sparked calls for a follow-up. Showrunners remain tight-lipped about a possible continuation, wanting to let the ending resonate with viewers.
| Character | Motivation | Fate (Season 1) |
|---|---|---|
| Chloe | Protect family | Keeps secret, frames Braddock |
| Nicky | Defend Chloe | Killed Adam, free |
| Ethan | Survival, identity | Acquitted, moves on |
| Adam | Abusive spouse | Murdered |
Why The Solution Matters
The revelation about who killed Adam Macintosh in The Better Sister was more than a whodunnit twist—it was a story about family, survival, and confronting painful truths. The show’s willingness to explore complex characters and moral ambiguities has set it apart in the crowded landscape of TV crime dramas.
As the series continues to dominate viewing charts and online discussions, one thing is certain: The question of Adam Macintosh’s killer was the catalyst for an unforgettable ride.
Have thoughts on the finale or want to share your theory about who killed Adam Macintosh in The Better Sister? Join the conversation below and let your voice be heard.