The spotlight shines brightly on Justin Baldoni once again, but not for his on-screen charisma or directorial flair. The It Ends With Us star and director recently faced a major blow when a judge dismissed his $400 million countersuit against Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds, their publicist Leslie Sloane, and The New York Times on June 9, 2025. This legal drama, rooted in allegations of defamation and extortion, has captivated Hollywood and fans alike. Baldoni’s attempt to counter Lively’s claims of sexual harassment and a retaliatory smear campaign didn’t hold up in court, marking a pivotal moment in this high-stakes feud.
Justin Baldoni’s Countersuit Crumbles
Baldoni’s legal team argued that Lively, Reynolds, and Sloane orchestrated a “character assassination plot” to tarnish his reputation. They claimed a text from a journalist, alleging Sloane labeled Baldoni a sexual predator, fueled their case. However, the journalist later clarified that Sloane never used the term “sexually assaulted,” weakening Baldoni’s argument. The judge, Lewis J. Liman, ruled that Lively’s statements in her California Civil Rights Department complaint were privileged, leading to the dismissal. Baldoni’s team can still amend claims for breach of contract or tortious interference, but the $400 million suit’s collapse is a significant defeat.
What’s Next for Justin Baldoni?
This ruling doesn’t end the saga. Baldoni, who also directed and produced It Ends With Us under his Wayfarer Studios, denies Lively’s allegations of on-set misconduct. The trial is set for March 2026, and both sides are digging in. Lively’s team accuses Baldoni of trying to dismantle laws protecting harassment victims, while his attorneys call her claims manipulative. The public remains divided, with some supporting Baldoni’s feminist public persona and others backing Lively’s allegations.
The Hollywood Ripple Effect
The case highlights tensions in Hollywood’s power dynamics. Justin Baldoni, once celebrated for his advocacy, now faces scrutiny over his conduct. The dismissal raises questions about accountability and the legal battles stars wage off-screen. Fans eagerly await the trial, where Lively plans to testify, potentially unveiling more details.
Stay updated on this unfolding drama by following entertainment news outlets for the latest developments.