How many people survived lethal injection? As of October 7, 2026, the answer depends on how the term is defined, but Christa Pike is the only confirmed person known to have survived after lethal-injection drugs were administered during a U.S. execution attempt.
Several other death-row prisoners have also survived attempted executions involving lethal injection. In those cases, however, officials stopped the procedures because they could not establish suitable intravenous access or complete the required medical process. Those individuals survived the execution attempts, but lethal drugs were not successfully administered as part of a completed execution.
The distinction has become especially important following a series of failed execution attempts across the United States and Tennessee’s unsuccessful attempt to execute Pike in September 2026.
Christa Pike’s 2026 Execution Attempt
Christa Pike’s case represents the most unusual lethal-injection failure documented in the United States.
Tennessee attempted to execute Pike on September 30, 2026. The state used pentobarbital as part of its lethal-injection procedure.
The execution did not result in Pike’s death.
Two doses of pentobarbital were administered during the attempt. Pike nevertheless remained alive and was eventually transferred for medical treatment.
Her attorneys later reported that she regained consciousness and was able to communicate. She remained seriously injured following the procedure.
The failed execution prompted an immediate examination of Tennessee’s execution process. The state halted its remaining scheduled executions for 2026 while officials reviewed what happened.
Pike’s survival is significant because previous well-known U.S. execution failures generally involved problems obtaining intravenous access before the lethal drugs could be successfully delivered.
Her case therefore created a new category in the history of American capital punishment: a condemned prisoner survived despite receiving lethal-injection medication during the execution attempt.
The Difference Between a Failed Execution and Surviving the Drugs
The number of people who have “survived lethal injection” can be confusing because the phrase can describe two different circumstances.
One category includes prisoners who survived an attempted lethal-injection execution. The procedure was stopped before lethal drugs were successfully delivered.
The second category consists of people who survived after receiving lethal-injection drugs during an execution attempt.
Under the narrower and medically significant definition, Christa Pike is the only confirmed survivor in the current U.S. record.
Under the broader definition, several additional prisoners belong in the count because they survived attempts in which lethal injection was the intended execution method.
The distinction is important when comparing individual cases.
Romell Broom and the 2009 Ohio Execution Failure
Romell Broom became one of the most recognized examples of a failed lethal-injection execution in the United States.
Ohio attempted to execute Broom on September 15, 2009.
Execution personnel spent roughly two hours attempting to establish an intravenous line. Multiple attempts were made to locate a suitable vein.
The process ultimately failed.
Ohio stopped the execution and returned Broom to death row.
Broom’s survival did not automatically eliminate his death sentence. The state later pursued another execution attempt, although that second execution never took place.
Broom died in prison in December 2020.
His case remains important because it demonstrated how an execution could be halted after prolonged efforts to establish IV access. It also became part of a broader national debate over whether states could reliably perform lethal injections when medical access proved difficult.
Alva Campbell’s Failed Ohio Execution
Ohio encountered another highly publicized failure in 2017.
Alva Campbell was scheduled for execution on November 15, 2017.
Campbell had severe health problems, including lung disease and other medical conditions. Those conditions complicated the effort to establish a suitable intravenous line.
Execution personnel attempted to locate a usable vein but could not successfully complete the procedure.
The state eventually stopped the execution.
Campbell survived the attempted execution and returned to prison.
He died several months later, in March 2018, after being found unresponsive in his prison cell.
Campbell’s case demonstrated another problem faced by execution teams: serious underlying medical conditions can make the process of establishing IV access considerably more difficult.
Doyle Hamm’s Alabama Execution Attempt
Doyle Hamm was scheduled to be executed in Alabama on February 22, 2018.
The state encountered substantial difficulty establishing intravenous access.
Hamm had several serious medical conditions, and execution personnel spent approximately two and a half hours attempting to establish the lines required for the procedure.
The execution was ultimately abandoned.
Hamm remained alive after the failed attempt.
His case later ended with an agreement that prevented Alabama from attempting to execute him again. Hamm died in November 2021 after suffering from cancer.
The circumstances surrounding his execution attempt became particularly notable because questions about his medical condition had been raised before the state proceeded.
Alan Miller Survived Alabama’s 2022 Attempt
Alan Miller’s case added another chapter to the history of failed lethal-injection executions.
Alabama attempted to execute Miller on September 22, 2022.
The execution team was unable to establish the necessary IV access before the state’s death warrant expired.
Officials called off the execution.
Miller survived.
His story did not end there. Alabama later selected nitrogen hypoxia as the method for carrying out his death sentence.
Miller was ultimately executed by nitrogen hypoxia in September 2024.
His case illustrates why a failed lethal-injection attempt does not necessarily mean a death sentence has been permanently abandoned. A state may seek another execution date or use a different method when state law permits it.
Kenneth Smith’s First Execution Attempt
Kenneth Smith also survived a failed lethal-injection attempt in Alabama.
The state attempted to execute Smith on November 17, 2022.
Officials were unable to establish adequate intravenous access before the execution warrant expired. The procedure was abandoned, and Smith remained alive.
Alabama later selected nitrogen hypoxia for his second execution attempt.
Smith was executed using nitrogen hypoxia on January 25, 2024.
His case attracted international attention because it became the first execution carried out using nitrogen hypoxia.
For purposes of counting survivors of attempted lethal injection, however, Smith remains one of the people who survived an initial lethal-injection attempt before later being executed through another method.
Thomas Creech’s Idaho Execution Attempt
Thomas Creech became another prominent example in 2024.
Idaho scheduled Creech’s execution for February 28, 2024.
Creech was taken to the execution chamber and secured to the execution gurney. Officials then attempted to establish the intravenous access needed to administer the lethal drugs.
The medical team made multiple attempts.
Those efforts were unsuccessful.
After approximately an hour, Idaho officials abandoned the execution.
Creech remained alive and was returned to prison.
The failure again highlighted the practical difficulty that can arise when execution personnel cannot establish reliable IV access.
Creech’s case is therefore included among failed lethal-injection executions, although he did not survive after receiving a completed dose of lethal drugs.
Tony Carruthers and Tennessee’s 2026 Failure
Before Pike’s case, Tennessee had another failed lethal-injection attempt in 2026.
Tony Carruthers was scheduled to be executed on May 21, 2026.
Tennessee’s execution team encountered problems establishing the required intravenous access.
Officials were unable to establish the necessary backup access and also attempted additional procedures to establish a central line.
The execution was eventually stopped.
Carruthers survived.
Tennessee Governor Bill Lee granted Carruthers a one-year reprieve following the failed execution attempt.
His case became particularly significant because it occurred only months before the state attempted to execute Pike.
Together, the two cases placed Tennessee’s execution procedures under increased scrutiny.
Why the Number Is Usually Reported Differently
Search results and historical discussions can produce different answers to the question of how many people survived lethal injection because there is no single universally used definition of “survived lethal injection.”
Some lists count anyone who survived an attempted lethal-injection execution.
Others count only prisoners who actually received the lethal drugs but remained alive.
These approaches produce different totals.
The broader group includes:
- Romell Broom
- Alva Campbell
- Doyle Hamm
- Alan Miller
- Kenneth Smith
- Thomas Creech
- Tony Carruthers
- Christa Pike
That gives eight known survivors of attempted U.S. executions in which lethal injection was the intended method.
However, Pike stands apart from the other cases because lethal-injection drugs were administered during her execution attempt.
That makes her the only confirmed person in this group who survived after receiving lethal-injection medication during the procedure.
What Happened After the Earlier Failed Attempts?
The eventual outcomes varied considerably.
Romell Broom remained on death row until his death in prison in 2020.
Alva Campbell died in prison in 2018, several months after Ohio abandoned his execution.
Doyle Hamm reached an agreement that prevented another execution attempt before he died in 2021.
Alan Miller was later executed using nitrogen hypoxia.
Kenneth Smith was also later executed using nitrogen hypoxia.
Thomas Creech remained alive after Idaho’s failed attempt.
Tony Carruthers received a reprieve following Tennessee’s unsuccessful procedure.
Christa Pike remained alive after Tennessee’s September 2026 attempt and received medical treatment afterward.
These outcomes show why surviving an execution attempt does not have one predictable legal consequence.
Does a Failed Lethal Injection Automatically Cancel a Death Sentence?
A failed execution does not automatically erase a death sentence.
The legal consequences depend on the state, the circumstances surrounding the failed execution, subsequent court proceedings and any agreements reached between the prisoner and government officials.
Some prisoners remain under their original death sentences.
Others may reach agreements preventing another attempt.
In some cases, states seek authorization for another execution using a different method.
Miller and Smith demonstrate that a failed lethal-injection attempt can be followed years later by an execution using another method.
Pike’s situation is different because the state administered lethal-injection medication before the attempt failed. The legal consequences of that event remain subject to further proceedings and review.
Why Christa Pike’s Case Has Changed the Historical Record
Before Pike’s 2026 execution attempt, the best-known U.S. lethal-injection failures involved problems with IV access.
Pike’s case introduced a different circumstance.
The state successfully administered two doses of pentobarbital, yet she survived.
That fact separates her case from the earlier examples involving Broom, Campbell, Hamm, Miller, Smith, Creech and Carruthers.
It also explains why current discussions about failed lethal injections must distinguish between a failure to establish an IV line and a failure occurring after lethal medication has already entered the body.
The difference is medically and legally significant.
Tennessee’s decision to suspend its remaining 2026 executions while the procedure was reviewed added another major development to the case.
The Current Answer to How Many People Survived Lethal Injection
So, how many people survived lethal injection?
Using the strict definition of surviving after lethal-injection drugs were administered, the confirmed number is one: Christa Pike.
Using the broader definition of surviving an attempted execution that was supposed to be carried out by lethal injection, eight people are known to have survived such attempts in the United States.
The eight are Romell Broom, Alva Campbell, Doyle Hamm, Alan Miller, Kenneth Smith, Thomas Creech, Tony Carruthers and Christa Pike.
The distinction is essential because seven of those cases involved execution attempts that failed before lethal drugs were successfully administered.
Pike’s case is different because the drugs were administered and she nevertheless remained alive.
As of October 7, 2026, her case remains the most significant recent development involving a failed U.S. lethal-injection execution. Her medical condition, Tennessee’s review and the legal questions surrounding the failed procedure will determine what happens next.
For anyone following the history of capital punishment in America, the difference between a failed execution attempt and surviving after lethal drugs are administered remains the key fact to remember.
