The upcoming FX limited series American Love Story, produced by Ryan Murphy, has stirred both anticipation and controversy as it prepares to dramatize the life, love, and tragic end of John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy. With filming underway in New York City and a premiere set for Valentine’s Day week 2026, the show is already making headlines—not just for its star-studded cast and creative vision, but for the heated debate it has sparked among the Kennedy family and fashion critics.
Jack Schlossberg, JFK Jr.’s nephew, recently took to Instagram to voice his frustration, confirming that his family was never consulted about the project. Schlossberg’s candid video, posted as he drove along the John F. Kennedy Memorial Highway, highlighted the family’s lack of control over how their loved ones are portrayed. He acknowledged that, under New York law, the right to privacy regarding name, image, and likeness does not survive death, and that JFK Jr. remains a public figure. Schlossberg expressed hope that the show would honor his uncle’s legacy and suggested that some profits be donated to the John F. Kennedy Library.
Who Were JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy?
John F. Kennedy Jr., often referred to as “America’s prince,” was the son of President John F. Kennedy and First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis. Born into one of the country’s most storied political families, JFK Jr. captured the public imagination with his charm, good looks, and commitment to public service. He became a magazine publisher and lawyer, but it was his marriage to Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy that truly captivated the nation.
Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy was a fashion publicist at Calvin Klein when she met JFK Jr. in the early 1990s. Renowned for her minimalist, effortlessly chic style, she quickly became an icon in her own right. The couple’s courtship and secret 1996 wedding were the subject of intense media scrutiny, and their relationship was both glamorous and fraught with the pressures of fame.
Their story ended tragically in July 1999, when the couple—along with Carolyn’s sister, Lauren—died in a plane crash off the coast of Martha’s Vineyard. JFK Jr. was piloting the aircraft in thick fog, resulting in a loss of control that shocked the world and left an indelible mark on American culture.
The Cast and Creative Vision of American Love Story
Ryan Murphy, known for his hit anthologies like American Horror Story and American Crime Story, has assembled a talented cast to bring this iconic couple to life. Paul Kelly, a newcomer, will portray JFK Jr., while Sarah Pidgeon—recently Tony-nominated for her performance in Stereophonic—will take on the role of Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy. Naomi Watts and Grace Gummer will play Jackie Onassis and Caroline Kennedy, respectively.
Murphy has emphasized the care taken in casting, with over a thousand actors considered for each lead role. In a recent Instagram post, he expressed excitement about the project and praised his team for finding “the perfect choices.” The series promises to explore the couple’s romance from their first meeting at Calvin Klein to their secret wedding and, ultimately, their tragic deaths.
Controversy and Criticism: Family, Fashion, and Public Reaction
Despite the creative ambition behind American Love Story, the project has not been without its detractors. Jack Schlossberg’s public criticism reflects a broader concern among the Kennedy family about the exploitation of their loved ones’ legacies for entertainment. Schlossberg clarified that while admiration for his uncle is welcome, he objects to “profiting off of it in a grotesque way.”
The controversy extends beyond family concerns. Early images from the set have drawn sharp criticism from fashion insiders, who argue that the costumes fail to capture Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy’s signature minimalist style. Fashion editors and stylists have called out the wardrobe choices as cheap imitations, with some industry heavyweights posting scathing critiques on social media.
Ryan Murphy has responded to the backlash, defending the costume choices and explaining that some early images were test shots. He pointed out that Carolyn was photographed wearing Converse sneakers in private, pre-fame photos, and emphasized the team’s commitment to authenticity. Murphy also addressed concerns about the hair color of Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn, noting that feedback from those who knew Bessette-Kennedy, like her former hair colorist Brad Johns, is being taken seriously.
Key Points Summary
- Premiere: American Love Story will debut on FX in Valentine’s Day week 2026.
- Main Cast: Paul Kelly as JFK Jr., Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, Naomi Watts as Jackie Onassis, Grace Gummer as Caroline Kennedy.
- Family Reaction: JFK Jr.’s nephew Jack Schlossberg has criticized the show for not consulting the family and for profiting from their tragedy.
- Legal Context: In New York, rights to privacy and control over name, image, and likeness do not survive death, especially for public figures.
- Fashion Controversy: Early images have drawn criticism for failing to capture Carolyn’s iconic style, prompting responses from Ryan Murphy and fashion insiders.
- Plot Focus: The series will chronicle the couple’s romance, wedding, and tragic deaths, set against the backdrop of intense media scrutiny.
Why American Love Story Matters Today
The enduring fascination with JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy speaks to the public’s appetite for stories of love, loss, and legacy. Their relationship, marked by both glamour and vulnerability, continues to resonate decades after their deaths. American Love Story aims to explore not just the tragedy, but the humanity behind the headlines.
Ryan Murphy’s approach—blending fact and drama—has the potential to introduce a new generation to this iconic couple, while also sparking important conversations about privacy, celebrity, and the ethics of dramatizing real-life tragedies. The series is poised to be a major cultural event, drawing in fans of history, fashion, and true crime alike.
Looking Ahead: What to Expect from American Love Story
As filming continues and more details emerge, viewers can expect a visually striking, emotionally charged series that dives deep into the complexities of fame and love. The casting of relative newcomers in the lead roles suggests a fresh perspective, while the involvement of seasoned actors like Naomi Watts adds gravitas.
The show’s creators have promised to treat the subject matter with respect, but the debate over authenticity and sensitivity is sure to continue. Whether American Love Story will be remembered as a fitting tribute or a controversial dramatization remains to be seen. For now, it stands as one of the most talked-about television projects of the year.
Share your thoughts on the upcoming series—will you be tuning in to watch American Love Story? Let us know in the comments below.