Alison Sweeney is back, delighting fans with her latest role in the Hallmark Mystery movie, Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, which premiered on June 22, 2025. The beloved actress, known for her long-running stint on Days of Our Lives and her knack for solving crimes as Hannah Swensen, teams up with Victor Webster for a thrilling new chapter in the popular mystery series. This latest installment has sparked buzz for its mix of suspense, romance, and even some unexpected physicality, as Webster recently revealed in an exclusive interview. Fans are raving about Sweeney’s return, and the movie’s fresh twists have kept viewers glued to their screens.
Alison Sweeney’s Return as Hannah Swensen
In Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, Alison Sweeney reprises her role as the charming baker-turned-sleuth Hannah Swensen. The story kicks off when a local actress, a rival of Hannah’s mother, Delores (played by Barbara Niven), is found murdered. Hannah, with her knack for uncovering clues, dives into the case alongside Victor Webster’s character, Chad. The duo’s chemistry is a highlight, with a fun twist involving a dance class where they learn to tango. Sweeney shared a behind-the-scenes glimpse on Instagram, showing her and Webster practicing their moves, which has fans buzzing about their on-screen dynamic.
The movie, which aired at 8 p.m. ET on Hallmark Mystery, marks Sweeney’s 12th appearance as Hannah Swensen. She also served as an executive producer and wrote the script, showcasing her multifaceted talents. The plot is personal for Hannah, as her mother becomes a prime suspect, adding emotional depth to the mystery. Fans have taken to social media, praising Sweeney’s ability to balance humor, heart, and sleuthing.
Key Point Summary:
- Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery premiered on June 22, 2025, on Hallmark Mystery.
- Alison Sweeney stars as Hannah Swensen, solving a murder tied to her mother.
- Victor Webster joins as Chad, with a notable tango scene adding flair.
- Sweeney wrote the script and served as executive producer.
Victor Webster’s Surprising Revelation
Victor Webster, a Days of Our Lives alum like Sweeney, recently shared in an exclusive interview that he was “shocked” by how physical the filming got for Pie to Die For. The movie includes action-packed moments that pushed the actors to new limits, from intense dance sequences to dynamic scenes during the investigation. Webster praised Sweeney’s producing skills, noting her ability to make challenging scenes feel seamless. Their shared history, including roles in The Wedding Veil trilogy, adds authenticity to their on-screen partnership.
This physicality has sparked excitement among fans, who appreciate the fresh energy in the series. Posts on X highlight the chemistry between Sweeney and Webster, with one fan calling their tango scene “electric.” The movie’s blend of romance and suspense has made it a standout in Hallmark’s 2025 lineup.
Beyond Pie to Die For, Alison Sweeney has been a force in 2025. She starred in two Hallmark rom-coms, To Barcelona, With Love and To Barcelona, Forever, alongside Ashley Williams. These films, part of Hallmark’s “Passport to Love” event, premiered on June 7 and June 14, respectively. Sweeney also launched a podcast, Mi Amor, with Williams, sharing behind-the-scenes stories from their Barcelona shoots. The podcast has been a hit, offering fans a peek into their friendship and filming adventures.
Sweeney’s commitment to her craft extends to philanthropy. On June 10, she joined Williams and Benjamin Ayres for an “InstaThon” to raise funds for cancer research, a cause close to her heart as a longtime ambassador for Stand Up To Cancer. Her ability to juggle acting, producing, writing, and charity work has cemented her as a fan favorite.
What’s Next for Alison Sweeney?
With Pie to Die For now streaming on Hallmark+, fans are already clamoring for more Hannah Swensen mysteries. Sweeney’s Instagram hints at future projects, with her caption, “Hello, June!!! I have a lot going on with
@hallmarkchannel this month!” fueling speculation about additional films. Her seamless blend of drama, comedy, and mystery keeps viewers hooked, and her collaboration with Webster suggests more exciting stories to come.
Sweeney’s return to Days of Our Lives in 2025 to mourn John Black’s passing also touched fans, though scheduling conflicts kept her character, Sami Brady, from the funeral episodes. She promised meaningful scenes later, showing her dedication to the soap that launched her career.
Conclusion
Alison Sweeney continues to captivate audiences with her talent and versatility. From solving murders in Pie to Die For to dancing through Barcelona in her rom-coms, she’s proving why she’s a Hallmark staple. The buzz around her latest mystery, amplified by Webster’s comments on its physical demands, has fans eagerly watching and sharing their excitement online. Whether she’s baking pies or cracking cases, Sweeney’s charm shines through. Don’t miss Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery on Hallmark+ for a dose of suspense and romance.
Tune in to Hallmark Mystery or stream on Hallmark+ to catch Alison Sweeney in action. Share your thoughts on Pie to Die For in the comments below!