America’s Next Top Model judges helped define modern fashion reality television, and their influence remains strong in 2026. Although the long-running competition series ended its last season in 2018, the panel members continue to shape conversations in modeling, media, and pop culture across the United States.
Over 24 cycles, the judging lineup shifted multiple times. Supermodels, editors, photographers, runway coaches, and public relations executives all brought their own standards and expectations to the competition. Each era of the show reflected a slightly different vision of what it meant to become “America’s next top model.”
Here is a comprehensive look at the most significant judges in the franchise’s history and where they stand today.
Tyra Banks: Creator, Executive Producer, and Lead Judge
Tyra Banks launched the series in 2003 and remained its central figure through nearly every cycle. She created the show, produced it, and led panel deliberations. Her presence shaped the tone, format, and direction of the competition.
Banks stepped away from hosting duties during Cycle 24 in 2018, when Rita Ora took over. However, Banks returned for the final season and remained executive producer until the series concluded.
In 2026, Banks continues to operate as an entrepreneur and media personality. Her SMiZE & Dream ice cream brand has expanded in recent years. She also maintains a strong presence in entertainment and business ventures. Banks remains closely associated with the show’s identity, and her name is still synonymous with the franchise.
Her judging style combined mentorship with high expectations. She often framed critiques around growth, branding, and confidence. Elimination moments became signature television events, with her dramatic delivery turning panel decisions into cultural touchpoints.
Janice Dickinson: The Original Tough Critic
Janice Dickinson served as one of the original judges from Cycles 1 through 4. She entered the show with an established modeling career and a reputation for bold opinions.
During her time on the panel, Dickinson delivered direct, sometimes harsh critiques. She challenged contestants to meet high-fashion standards and pushed them to present themselves professionally at all times.
After leaving the series in 2005, Dickinson continued working in media and fashion. She remains active in interviews and public appearances. Her role during the early seasons helped set the show’s sharp-edged tone and established panel tension as a core element of the format.
Nigel Barker: The Photographer’s Eye
Nigel Barker joined the panel in Cycle 2 and remained through Cycle 18. As a fashion photographer, he focused heavily on the technical aspects of modeling. Lighting, posture, expression, and camera connection all factored into his critiques.
Barker became one of the longest-serving judges in the franchise’s history. His feedback often balanced constructive advice with industry realism. He rarely relied on theatrics, instead emphasizing practical improvement.
Since departing the show in 2012, Barker has continued working as a photographer, filmmaker, and creative director. He frequently participates in fashion events and maintains an active professional profile.
His contributions helped viewers understand how modeling functions behind the scenes. He translated industry standards into accessible commentary for a mainstream audience.
J. Alexander (Miss J): Runway Authority
J. Alexander, known widely as Miss J, began as the show’s runway coach before serving as a judge in multiple cycles. His training sessions became fan favorites and added a theatrical element to each episode.
Miss J specialized in runway presence. He worked closely with contestants on posture, pacing, and confidence. His critiques at panel often focused on performance during live walks and fashion show challenges.
In 2026, he remains active in fashion education and international modeling work. His influence extended beyond critique. Many contestants credited him with improving their runway skills dramatically over the course of a season.
Miss J brought humor and personality to panel discussions, but he maintained strict standards for professionalism. That balance made him one of the most memorable figures in the show’s history.
André Leon Talley: High-Fashion Credibility
André Leon Talley joined the judging panel during Cycles 14 through 17. As a longtime fashion editor and industry authority, he elevated the show’s connection to elite fashion institutions.
Talley offered commentary rooted in couture tradition and editorial sophistication. He assessed contestants through the lens of global fashion standards rather than purely commercial appeal.
His presence marked a shift toward a more fashion-centric era of the competition. He encouraged contestants to think beyond reality television exposure and toward international runway and editorial success.
Talley passed away in January 2022. His legacy in fashion journalism and cultural representation remains significant. During his time on the show, he strengthened its credibility within the broader fashion community.
Kelly Cutrone: Branding and Business Focus
Kelly Cutrone joined the panel beginning in Cycle 18, also known as the “British Invasion” season. As a public relations executive, she brought a strong business perspective.
Cutrone evaluated contestants based on marketability and brand identity. She focused less on technical posing and more on long-term career potential. Her critiques often centered on professionalism, communication skills, and adaptability in commercial settings.
She remained with the show through Cycle 22. Since then, Cutrone has continued leading her public relations firm and appearing in media commentary related to fashion and branding.
Her presence reflected the evolving modeling industry, where personal branding and social visibility increasingly matter.
Rita Ora: A New Host for the Final Cycle
Rita Ora hosted Cycle 24 in 2018, marking the only season without Tyra Banks as host. That season aired on VH1 and represented the show’s final installment.
Ora served as both host and judge. Her experience in music and entertainment brought a different energy to the panel. She emphasized performance skills, personality, and public image.
After the series concluded, Ora continued her music career and television appearances. Cycle 24 remains the most recent chapter in the franchise’s history.
Other Notable Judges Over the Years
While the names above defined major eras, several additional industry professionals appeared as recurring or permanent judges in various cycles. These included fashion editors, stylists, and creative directors who contributed to the evolving panel dynamic.
The changing lineup allowed the show to adjust its focus across time. Early seasons leaned heavily into modeling fundamentals. Later seasons highlighted branding, social media presence, and cross-industry opportunities.
Franchise Status in 2026
The original run aired on The CW before ending in 2015. VH1 revived the series for Cycles 23 and 24, concluding in 2018.
As of February 2026:
- No new season has been announced
- No official revival has been confirmed
- The series continues to stream on select platforms
- Former judges remain active in their respective industries
Interest in the show persists. Clips from earlier cycles regularly circulate on social media. Fans often revisit iconic panel moments and debate the strongest judges in the franchise’s history.
Lasting Cultural Influence
The impact of America’s Next Top Model judges extends beyond television ratings. The panel format influenced numerous reality competitions that followed. Dramatic eliminations, structured critiques, and industry-specific mentorship became staples in similar programs.
The show also contributed to broader conversations in fashion. It showcased diverse body types, backgrounds, and identities long before inclusivity became a central industry theme. Judges frequently addressed representation, professionalism, and confidence on camera.
Panel discussions shaped public understanding of modeling as both art and business. Viewers gained insight into casting decisions, photo shoot strategy, and runway expectations.
Why the Judges Still Matter
Even without new episodes, the judges remain culturally relevant. Tyra Banks continues as a business leader. Nigel Barker remains active in photography. Kelly Cutrone continues shaping branding conversations. Miss J stays influential in runway coaching circles.
Their critiques, personalities, and standards continue to define how many Americans remember the franchise. For longtime fans, the judging panel represents the core of the show’s appeal.
The combination of mentorship, competition, and personality-driven commentary helped the series stand out during its peak years. That formula remains recognizable today in other fashion and talent-based reality programs.
Which judge had the greatest impact on the competition? Share your perspective and follow for the latest confirmed updates about the franchise.