Andrew Barth Feldman Shines in Broadway’s Latest Star Turn

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ │
│ Key Points Summary │
│ │
│ – Andrew Barth Feldman joins “Maybe Happy Ending” │
│ for a 9-week Broadway run, starting September 2, 2025. │
│ – Feldman replaces Darren Criss as “Oliver” at the │
│ Belasco Theatre. │
│ – He co-stars onstage with real-life partner Helen J Shen.│
│ – The run marks a major, anticipated return to Broadway │
│ post-“Dear Evan Hansen.” │
│ – Creators and fans express excitement for Feldman’s role.│
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Andrew Barth Feldman is making waves this summer as he prepares for a prominent return to Broadway. The highly acclaimed young actor, who rose to fame leading “Dear Evan Hansen,” has been officially announced as the next star to take on the role of Oliver in the Tony Award-winning musical “Maybe Happy Ending.” Fans and theatre insiders alike are celebrating this casting, and the buzz for Feldman’s limited engagement is already building as September approaches.

The excitement is well-earned. Feldman’s run as Oliver will begin at New York’s Belasco Theatre on September 2, 2025, continuing through November 1, 2025. He steps into the role following the much-applauded tenure of Darren Criss, whose last performance is scheduled for August 31. “Maybe Happy Ending” has received major acclaim this year, winning the 2025 Tony Award for Best Musical, and Feldman’s addition to the cast signals a new chapter for the production.

One element drawing extra attention is Feldman’s onstage partnership with Helen J Shen, who originated the role of Claire. The two, who are a couple offstage, will now bring their chemistry to the Belasco’s spotlight. Feldman himself has commented on the experience, expressing deep gratitude and delight at joining the established company and sharing the stage with Shen. He described joining the cast as “an honor beyond words” and is thrilled to be working alongside a “brilliant team and beautiful company”.

The creative team has shared their own excitement, highlighting Feldman’s “emotionally honest” and “musically gifted” approach to the role. Feldman even played a pivotal part in Helen J Shen’s original audition for the show, reading opposite her for her tape. It’s a full-circle moment now that they’ll both be onstage together, drawing on their personal connection and dramatic strengths.

For longtime fans, Andrew Barth Feldman’s Broadway homecoming is a compelling follow-up to his celebrated turns in “Dear Evan Hansen” and “Little Shop of Horrors.” Over the past year, Feldman also impressed off-Broadway audiences in “We Had a World,” playing at New York City Center earlier in 2025. He’s kept his creative output broad, dabbling in film and supporting theatre projects. But it is the live stage that truly showcases his remarkable singing and acting talents, and anticipation for his take on Oliver is high.

What makes this casting especially notable is the context it brings to “Maybe Happy Ending,” a moving story about two obsolete helper robots who discover love and the meaning of being human. Feldman’s portrayal is expected to bring new emotional dimensions to the role, mixing humor, vulnerability, and vibrant musicality.

For those looking to see Feldman in action, tickets for “Maybe Happy Ending” are already in demand. The limited nine-week run promises to be a major theatrical event of the fall. In addition to Shen, the ensemble remains packed with talent, featuring Dez Duron, Marcus Choi, and a skilled group of understudies.

Theatre community reactions are overflowing with praise, and fans of live performance in New York are eager to witness this unique combination of talent. Below is a quick snapshot of what to expect in Feldman’s latest act:

The months ahead promise not just career milestones, but also memorable, heartfelt performances from a star who continues to inspire theatergoers of all ages. Andrew Barth Feldman is set to leave his unique mark on Broadway once again, offering audiences an experience powered by genuine artistry and authenticity. If you plan to be in Manhattan during this special run, this is a show—and an actor—you won’t want to miss.

What are your thoughts on Andrew Barth Feldman’s return to Broadway? Share your excitement, favorite performances, or ticket plans in the comments below—let the conversation begin!